Jojan makes a single and a multi fletching jig. Which one do you have? Is it a straight clamp or Helical. If it is straight, it can accept either left or right wing feathers. Follow what McDave said. If it is Helical the left can be used with left wing feathers and the curve needs to match the shaft. Set the bottom slightly to the right of the index on the nock, and the top slightly to the left. Just the opposite for RT wing jigs. If nothing seems to work, check the instructions you have, or available online. If you were using wood shafts the setting will be different than for the smaller graphite shafts. If you wood shafts are parallel and you switch to a tapered, it may need to be reset.