This came up on another site (LW) and I did a little test...see thread Epitaph II: pics

I shoot my cedars better the my aluminums...I dont shoot carbons yet.

I like shooting the cedars...someone raised a concern about carbon fibers that might remain in the animal if the arrow breaks.  Wood will soften, carbon will just stick into the roof of your mouth or gums!  Anybody else had this concern?

It really doesn't matter what kinda shaft material yer arras are made with, what counts most is can you hit yer mark consistently.

just bought  some carbons today
shot aluminum most of the time
well see in a little while

That header made me wonder "What you smokin in that pipe?"        

It's too bad Howard Hill never had the chance to take shooting lessons from you guys, he would have finally been able to hit something once and a while.  Really now, I have both and when the arrow works, it works no matter what it is made out of.  It is possible that some just don't know how to get cedars to work for them.

LOL good point!   I just never liked how much work they take then they break so easy.  

I think i'm goina go back to ceders. I like the feel of the shot better with wood compared to carbons.

I think I'm going back to wood too.  I just like the looks and feel and they shoot plenty good enough. Less monkeying around adding weight, etc.

Tripp, Haven't you learned, YET?!  Carbon has no SOUL!  Wood has a Spirit!