...about a guy (I think his name was Curt or Curtis) who shot a doe and she had grass packed in her mouth to surround a broadhead which turned out to be his from the year before.

I remember the story, but not the title of it. It was Curtis Keller who posted as Littlefeather here.  Good writing - I miss seeing him here.

Try this link...  I think it's what you're looking for...

http://tradgang.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=90;t=000243#000014

Jonathan

Great, thanks guys!