I own both, and will not disclose which I like better because the only reason is personal.
I can pick up either and have total confidence while walking into the woods.

I have never shot a TallTines but I have drooled over many. Now I do own and hunt with a Paul Schafer Silvertip, and having owned and shot many other top of the line bows, I can honestly say my Silvertip will hold its own in all the areas of performance, and surpass in others. This bow is forgiving, very quiet, dead in the hand, and was a pleasure to tune! Did I mention fast. I have never shot a Windauer Tip, but have always heard great things about Dave's bows. If you ever get a chance to get your hands on a Paul Schafer Silvertip, Take full advantage of the situation, you will not regret it! God bless, and good huntin. Gary.  

I have not shot a Silvertip but have owned a number of Tall Tines and they are a fantastic bow. I see you own a Toelke Lynx. Have you considered having Dan and Jared make you a set of recurve limbs for that? I currently have 2 sets of recurve limbs for my lynx and absolutely love it. Plenty quick, light in the hand, and quiet as a church mouse.
Just a thought!!

QuoteOriginally posted by bowtough:
I have never shot a TallTines but I have drooled over many. Now I do own and hunt with a Paul Schafer Silvertip, and having owned and shot many other top of the line bows, I can honestly say my Silvertip will hold its own in all the areas of performance, and surpass in others. This bow is forgiving, very quiet, dead in the hand, and was a pleasure to tune! Did I mention fast. I have never shot a Windauer Tip, but have always heard great things about Dave's bows. If you ever get a chance to get your hands on a Paul Schafer Silvertip, Take full advantage of the situation, you will not regret it! God bless, and good huntin. Gary.      

I've own bows made by Paul, and Dave.
Dave took a phenominal bow of Paul's design, and continues to improve on it. The performance is better now than ever.
That being said, it is a magical thing to shoot a Tip made by Paul himself! In a class all by itself just for this reason!

IMO,
You could blind fold a guy and have him shoot both and he couldn't tell you which was which.
I found the Tip to have a slight edge in craftsmanship.

Black Widow PSA 60"

I have owned both, still have 3 Silvertips and one on order. Only recurves I own now, they just fit me. Nothing wrong with a TT but the Tips just fit me better.

Don't think you can go wrong either way.