I've been shooting a super glove for years, but have got the itch to try a tab, the super glove has cordovan tips and I'd like to try a tab with a similar feel, so I'm looking for suggestions for one that will feel the same.  

I like the 3r cordovan tab I shoot.

Black Widow, and Eagles Flight are two of my favorites.

BW

Bateman cordovan hands down best tab I have tried.

I have used the Black Widow, calf hair and the Bateman cordovan.  I prefer the Bateman Cordovan over the BW.

I have Bateman, Jenkins, and Cavalier. The Cavalier elite is my favorite, primarily because I can feel the string but my fingers are well protected. It is split finger but I shoot 3 under with no issues. Of course I don't use the spacer or the jaw plate.

I can hear it now.....

"I'da had that bunny if I was still shooting my superglove and not fumbling with this &%$#!%# tab!!!!!!"

     

The Bateman cordavan is my #1 favorite.

Bateman cordovan here also.  I also have a Cavalier and an Eichler but much prefer the Bateman.

Make your own...

     

 

hey Curt...a man should always be prepared      

I don't know that any tab will feel like a glove

Another vote for the Bateman here.  Closest feel to a glove would probably be a Super tab, tho.

The tab that finally got me to switch from a glove is the AAE Cavalier Elite Cordovan.

thanks guys, I just ordered up a Bateman tab. Looks like that should have the closest feel on the string as the glove I'm shooting now.

BW and Bateman