The wife bought some arrows that were spined too heavily, got them returned. Looking at the Easton Legacy aluminum shafts, the 2117 were grossly over spined, what spine should I get? Shooting a 50# @28 Hawkeye recurve.

1916's fly great out of my 50# hoyt buffalo.

Maybe even some Good Tip traditional, not sure which yet, think I prefer the aluminum

Actual Draw Length?
Point Weight?

Without this info, all you'll get are guesses.

My draw length varies between 28-28.5 going to be shooting 160 grain field points to match up with the zwickey screw in broadheads, either delta or eskimos

would a 2018 be a good arrow? added weight for hunting.  depending on length of course

2016's

 

2016 with a 125gr tip

I'd go with 2016 or 3555 if you decide to get the Gold Tip trads.

Anything over 29 will work, probably going to order 31.5 so I can do a little cutting if necessary

2016's should be good, if you are leaving them a little long or using a heavy point you might need 2018's

I use Goldtips, they are awesome and don't have a high price tag.