Hi Drake! I live in Mt Pleasant and am about 50 mile east of you. There are a few trad shooters around your area. Hopefully they will chime in, (bowmac where are you Bro!). I have never hunted around Rathbun, but I do know that the fishing is good (crappie, walleye and catfish)! Lacy and Shimek also have good public hunting and alot of ground. There are also some inside city limit hunts in some cities, although you do need to take a class and proficiency test. Some cities (like Fairfield I believe) have late season archery in the parks in town, otherwise it is private land only. Wapello Chiefs is not a trad only club, but they do have a great trad shoot and some trad members. ITBS has a good shoot in Ames Memorial weekend and it is an all trad event and always a great time.
Where did you move from?