Not sure how these paper tears look, I know I don't have a perfect release but do these look pretty close to a tuned arrow?

Look's like a bit high nock tear.  What distance were you shooting this at?

Fairly close, maybe 4 feet away, the guy who showed me how to paper test said you wanted to be close, not sure if that's correct. Some new arrows Im trying to work with, think there good to go as far as spine? Thanks!

If you can't shoot a bare shaft straight in at 15 yrds. then you need help. Experience= 56 years of shooting a bow. Just my thoughts.

These are fletched arrows to, have some bare shafts I could use too

I've paper tuned for a very long time. I'd be quite satisfied with those near "bullet-hole" tears.  Your picture isn't quite straight on so I can't tell for sure.

I shoot from 6-8' and then again at 21'. Fletched arrows.

Here's a recent tuning session of mine.  You can see that shots 1 and 2 were nock high with a 1/4" high nocking point. I adjusted up to 5/8" and shot 3 and 4 bullet holes. Then I checked at 21'.

I think they make your butt look fat.    
homebru
PS Sorry, I don't know what overcame me but I couldn't resist.