At 6', I think I would go with the 58"

What ever you go with you well like it better than the PSA they just shoot great.

'Vernon at BW has strongly suggested that I go with a 58".'

I'd say there is your answer.....unless there is a DEFINITE reason you MUST have a shorter bow for a certain scenario.

I think I would trust the guy making the bow, unless there is a real obvious reason not to.

I appreciate all the help with this decision.  My mind is at much more ease now after getting some responses.  You know, my gut feeling was to go with what Vernon had recommended, but when I spend this kind of money, and there are this many options, my mind tends to mess with me.