What would he score??

[Ontario Longbow]

OK all you field judging experts,, What would the first buck score,, I'm thinking 3 1/2 year old 110 p&y,, Any thoughts on the trailing buck?,, Thanks for your input,, Frank


Two more views:

[RightTrailWrongTime]

My non expert opinion would put him at 2 1/2, he's maybe 17 inches wide, 7 or 8 inch G2s 3 inch G3s maybe 3 inch brows, not much mass- I think he might still go around 100-110 though hard to say without puttin the tape to him but I'm not one to do that if you want em take em! I'd let him grow another year if you can stand it but trophys are to each his own. He's got great potential and nice early structure. Really cool to get him on trailcam...nice photos

[woodchucker]

I'd say 8 points,right on the money.....    

[Wannabe1]

My opinion would be they're alien with those weird eyes!         Should score right up there with the FEDS!            

Sorry, it has been a long day.

[amar911]

About 100 or maybe a little less. Not much length or mass. He is a pretty little deer. He definitely is not 3 1/2 years old. He is no more than 2 1/2 in my opinion. Of course, I don't know the area, so maybe the antler growth is different there. The body is also very slim with no belly hanging down and no look of age anywhere else. The trailing buck is obviously much smaller and probably 1 1/2 years old. Looks like a pretty small six point, but I can't make him out sufficiently to guess at a score.

Allan

[StickBowManMI]

I agree that he is probably 2 1/2 years old and given another year his rack should be better. Pass on him now and wait two years and you will have a nice buck.

[JimB]

That rack is pretty wide.the ears should be 16".I'm also guessing those deer are bigger framed than most of us are used to looking at.

[Wary Buck]

Decent brows, beams, G2s, and very nice spread for a younger buck.  Weak on the mass and G3s.  100-105" maybe.  If it's a buck that trips your trigger, his score shouldn't matter; good luck!

[Slasher]

WIth width like that, He'd get dropped on any property I hunt here in GA... I'll hazard a guess of 105-110 as mass is low and not enough tine length to really add anything of consequant value... But I am not really into scoring...

As for shoot/no shoot- that's your call.. Me if it was a hard earned trophy that I'd treasure the memories of the hunt, he'd be on my wall... But if he just happenned bye and was just an okay deer for my area, I think he'd walk...

[52 bow]

How did you attatch the golf balls to their eyes???? 108 gross but tasty!

[carparcher]

He shoots, he scores!  That's the way I look @ it.  Cool pics, thanks for sharing.  

[Shawn Leonard]

I would say 105-110"s gross with deductions he under 100"s, his right side is shorter at every tine. The second buck is probably 2.5 and I would say 90-95"s gross. Shawn

[Ontario Longbow]

Great in-sight guys,,Thanks!! ,,Frank