Not wanting to hijack the other thread I thought I would ask this in a new one.
What trad only shoots DO NOT allow the use of binoculars?
I'm just curious about it, because in the many years I have been shooting trad only shoots only one organization's shoots I attended did not allow them, and even they have changed their rules to allow them now.
I have not been to one that does NOT allow them yet.
How aren't binoculars trad? Rangefinders are commonly banned. I get that. Usually just no binos at the stake.
Again, to the best of my recollection I have never attended a Traditional Archery 3d shoot that allowed binoculars! The only pair I ever recall seeing was pulled out by a shooter who was gently informed that they were not allowed by rule. He apologized as he did not know and put them away. In 2009 near Belleville, IL. I did compete in two 3d shoots that were in large majority compound bow events. My group was all trad shooters. We were very courteously treated and allowed to "hopscotch' around the groups who seemed to all have binoculars, many with chairs and come back to the stake later.
North American Longbow Safari does not allow any binoculars.
It varies on the club I have found TBoT does not allow. Mixed shoots usually do.
:thumbsup:
Tbot does allow. They started allowing them a couple years ago.
In their currently posted rules.
#5-Binoculars are allowed at all TBoT tournaments, but shall not be used once the shooter is at the shooting stake. No rangefinders allowed.
I'm not sure if the shoots in my area allow them or not but no one uses them that I've ever seen shooting traditional bows. To me it adds a little excitement to a shoot when everyone eyeballs the target, takes the shot and you walk to the target and get to yell back "Hey Bill, you got an 11 (or 12)!".
To answer Bear Heart, I don't think many members here think of binoculars as being "trad" or "non-trad". One of the many appeals of traditional archery is the simplicity of equipment. A strung bow, glove or tab, arrows and a quiver suffice for a huge majority of your shooting, including 3d shoots. If you allow binoculars, face it you will need a pair to be competitive. As useful as they are in hunting, to me they will become just another piece of crap that I don't really need to carry around to shoot 3d targets and if no one has them, no one has any unfair advantage. Finally, ask yourself if anyone when hunting (which 3d is intended to simulate) uses binoculars to find an aiming point when game is within 10 to 20 yards and immediately before nocking and arrow and shooting?
I personally have never been to a trad shoot that does not allow binoculars. Not every one uses them, but all have the option.
If some one don't think that binoculars are fair, I would suggest taking the matter up with the club or organization that allows them.
I always try to play a game by the rules, 3D shoots are a game. Some shoots have different rules. Heck some TX Trad Shoots allow raised arrow rest, some don't. When I show up and see Olympic bows at a trad shoot that allows them, I just go have fun with my friends. At that point it is just for fun anyways. :)
I do not see a problem with using them before or after you get to the stake but not at the stake.
I have been to shoots and there is a new animal or the people before me almost pushed the target down. I pick my spot and drill it. We then walk up and the animal is leaning or turned so the scoring rings are not where I felt they should be. I get a 5, my buddy, who says a few choice words when he flinched and almost shot over the animals back gets a 10.
I don't keep my score anymore, I just shoot to have fun...
Makes it hard to birdwatch while other folks shoot, if you can't bring them.
I can see where some folks could cheat by using a rangefinder incorporated into the bino unit. I can't help but think that looking at a "stolen" prize would give the cheater a sour stomach. I refuse to take scoring seriously. I use it to monitor personal performance, and if I get an "Atta Girl" trophy from it, then it just helps to preserve the memory of a day in the woods with my buddies.
Killdeer
Well said Killie :thumbsup:
The IBO allows use of binoculars at all their events including the trad worlds.
QuoteOriginally posted by Killdeer:
Makes it hard to birdwatch while other folks shoot, if you can't bring them.
I can see where some folks could cheat by using a rangefinder incorporated into the bino unit. I can't help but think that looking at a "stolen" prize would give the cheater a sour stomach. I refuse to take scoring seriously. I use it to monitor personal performance, and if I get an "Atta Girl" trophy from it, then it just helps to preserve the memory of a day in the woods with my buddies.
Killdeer
This exact thing HAS happened with a very high level pro compound shooter on the ASA circuit. He was banned and stripped of his titles! He should have been thrown in jail because he was a pro and doing it for money!
Cheaters are going to cheat, no matter!
Just about every trad shoot anywhere around my neck of the woods allows binoculars. The only one I can think of in TX that does not is the Texas State Longbow Championship shoot.
Bisch
Out here [AZ] most trad stakes have a 30 yard plus or minus 10% [30meter] max. For people whose eyes can't see the rings it's nice to use binos. We all use them to hunt. So learning to shoot well while wearing them is good practice.
MAP
TBA shoots do not allow binos. I dont care either way
I've been shooting competition for over 30 years.
At the mixed shoots I've seen the use of binoculars slow things down.
At the all trad shoots I've not once seen the use of binoculars even remotely slow things down.
I've actually seen people take much longer at the shooter stake because they didn't have binoculars, and couldn't quickly figure out where they needed to place their arrow. The people with the binos scan with them for 3 or 4 seconds, and make their shot.
The biggest hold up I have ever experienced at any shoot (trad or otherwise) was people looking for their arrows behind the target. Makes me wonder if they were using binoculars or not. :p
Maybe I'm just being silly... (or missing something?)
I don't use binos for hunting... Why would I use them for a 3-D shoot?????
From what I've seen, The scoreing rings are "generic" at best. If I put it in the crease, it's "dead game"... That's all I'm worried about!
When I am shooting 3d it is for score and I am trying to shoot the best score I can. Some of the smaller targets 11 ring is smaller than a dime,and not where you would think it should be for hunting situation, so I use my binos on probably 15 out of 30 target's,I don't think it slows anyone down, because it's done before I get to the stake. And for all those that argue 3d messes up your hunting because the 11 ring is not a double lung shot I say this. If you can hit a dime, you can hit a dime wherever it is.
The issue arises when a 3D target is set up to trick you. Instead of broadside, it is set up quartering slightly towards you. A true killing shot will give you a 5.
The 12 is way off to the side which no one can really see.
If you are shooting for hunting practice, who cares....shoot for a true kill shot.
If shooting to compete, you better know where the 12 ring is or the bino guy next to you will smoke your score.
I like the k-w-m scoring system. Used it a couple of years ago at the local club and got some weird stares at first,but kill,wound, and miss said it all for me.
As far as the binoculars go I rarely leave home without my 6x32's. Here in Pa. there are antler restrictions and I would rather be safe than sorry.
Good Shooting,
Craig
I don't need binoculars. I am a traditional archer. I know all kills are at the normal place, so I focus on that spot.
As for rangefinders; I am a traditional archer. So knowing the distance wouldn't change a bit. I just aim and release.
I think binoculars or rangefinders don't belong on a3d shoot, they slow things down indeed.
As for people who cheat during a 3d shoot: I hate them. Alas, more and more archers tend to cheat. They kill our sport!
Like Killy I don't take the scores seriously anymore, my starting point us how well I shoot ( or how poor sometimes :) )
Mine five cents....
Not that it matters to me one bit but to answer your question, the annual Kentucky Tradfest hosted by the KTBA prohibits the use of binoculars at that event. Spectacular shoot and I couldn't care less about allowing the use of binoculars or not. Sometimes I take binos to 3D shoots that allow them and sometimes I don't.
Binoculars are allowed at all TBoT tournaments, but shall not be used once the shooter is at the shooting stake. No rangefinders allowed.
Here is the binocular rule for Tbot.