Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: mnbearbaiter on March 11, 2010, 01:50:00 AM

Title: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: mnbearbaiter on March 11, 2010, 01:50:00 AM
I was just wondering if and what changes any of you make throughout the season to your arrows? If you change the game you pursue do you cater your setup a little more to it or not? Like shooting heavier arrows than you would for deer if you go on a elk, caribou, moose, bear hunt! Do any of you change broadheads to mazimize penetration, things like that! I personally use the same heavy arrows for deer, turkey, and bear, as well as the same broadheads! If i were to go on a Pronghorn hunt though i feel that a lighter arrow may gain a few yards of trajectory of my current setup which has a decent arc after about 30yds, that sort of thing!
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Earthdog on March 11, 2010, 01:58:00 AM
Like you,I never change something I already know works.

Apart from some experimenting with different broadheads,and up grading arrows as newer an better types come on the market,,,I still shoot 99% Old Bear Razors and heavy arrows for everything.

The Bears have been my standard for 40 years,The same alloys for 20 years,then changed to GoldTips for around 15 years,resently switched to Carbon express,but still shoot Bear Razorheads for most of my hunting.

If I was hunting Rabbits today but Feral Cattle tomorrow,I'd change nothing.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Benny Nganabbarru on March 11, 2010, 02:04:00 AM
Absolutely. I have pig arrows, and buffalo arrows; they're two different things entirely.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: jeff vess on March 11, 2010, 03:17:00 AM
I use the same arrows for everything I hunt. I try to find a happy median of an arrow that is heavy enough for elk but still fast enough for antelope. I shoot mfx classics that weight 555 grains out of a 63# bow and get good speed and great penetration on elk. But I always shoot the same arrows even on turkeys or when shooting 3-d's or stumps.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: ozy clint on March 11, 2010, 04:11:00 AM
same arrows for everything except heavier ones just for buffulo.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: JC on March 11, 2010, 06:45:00 AM
I tune my arrows for my different bows, or different limb/riser combos, and that almost always gives me different weight arrows. I will shoot a heavier arrow out of a heavier bow and usually only go to the heavier limbs if I'm going to a place where there might be big hogs. Otherwise, my bows usually only have one arrow setup each.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: COOCH on March 11, 2010, 06:55:00 AM
No I set my eguiptment up for the big critters and know that If it works on them it will work on the smaller stuff also.Don't fix what isn't broke.When I get in the mood to change something I'll buy a new bow and start from scratch.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Richie Nell on March 11, 2010, 07:29:00 AM
Stealthy 1000 grainers for 12 yard shots on deer and 800 grainers for elk allowing for further flatter shot.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: GMMAT on March 11, 2010, 08:16:00 AM
I certainly will.

Around here, whitetails RARELY reach 200#'s.  My 3-blade WW's are fine.

When I go to CO, this fall, I'll be switching off to a 2-blade Silver Flame....to ensure maximum penetration.  Needed?  Who knows?  Peace of mind, though?  Certainly.

I also JUST made a similar post to yours RE: building the perfect "hog" arrow.  I'm wondering if I need to foot that arrow or not.

I'm also hoping the overall weight I'm shooting is sufficient for hogs (10gpp).  I don't really want to be changing up my OVERALL setup.

Great question.  I'll be following this one, intently.

Thanks for the information, guys.  It's why I love this place!
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: cacciatore on March 11, 2010, 08:24:00 AM
I do.If I hunt from a tree stand in single digit temperatures for long hours I don't need and I can manage the same bow and arroe I use for elk hunting.Anyway most of my set up are pretty similar never going under 10 gfp and over 13.If I'll decide to hunt something like a buffalo maybe I'll need to change again.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Longbow338 on March 11, 2010, 08:33:00 AM
I use the same heads and arrows all year and would feel comfortable shooting any game animal in north america with it.  I do however like to try different broadheads of the same weight.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: ChuckC on March 11, 2010, 09:21:00 AM
Very often I carry different arrows for different game.  I may have a skwerl arrow, a rabbit arrow, a deer arrow and a coyote arrow all at the same time.  When turkey season rolls around. .  yet another arrow.
ChuckC
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Jason R. Wesbrock on March 11, 2010, 09:56:00 AM
If I hunted animals like Ben of Clint pursue (up to buffalo) I certainly would change things. But since I know my setup will work well on everything from squirrels to moose, I stay with the same arrows year round. As a matter of fact, the only difference between my target arrows and my hunting arrows are field points versus broadheads.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Rob DiStefano on March 11, 2010, 10:09:00 AM
though i do dabble with lotsa different bows, i mostly shoot my 'go to' longbow and as jason does, i shoot  just one arrow type/weight and change the matched weighted heads for the task at hand ... from hunting broadhead to roving judo to target field point.  i like to think that familiarity breeds accuracy.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: straitera on March 11, 2010, 01:00:00 PM
The same for everything although I might add heavier BH if after moose or elk.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: dave19113 on March 11, 2010, 01:14:00 PM
Im with Rob... I love to dabble... Just an excuse to buy a new broadhead. But my go to arrow is a 2219 cut to 28" with 275 up front of ace 2blades or Magnus vented out of my 66# 60"

I like going heavy... some might even say too heavy but I like em... Now if I was going for grizzly or african game I would have to come up with a new one
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Orion on March 11, 2010, 01:17:00 PM
I use a heavier bow and arrows for elk and bigger critters than I do for deer.  Broadheads are often the same.  I usually carry Abowyers, Stos and/or Zwickeys.  Shoot my heavier set-up most of the summer.  Big critter hunting is early fall.  Pull out the lighter stuff for when I'll be hunting whitetails dark to dark in northern Wisconsin during November.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Encino Man on March 11, 2010, 01:26:00 PM
Like Rob said.

 
Quotei shoot just one arrow type/weight and change the matched weighted heads for the task at hand ... from hunting broadhead to roving judo to target field point. i like to think that familiarity breeds accuracy.
Since accuracy is the most important aspect of a clean kill, I like to keep the same flight.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: jrchambers on March 11, 2010, 02:26:00 PM
ill change broadheads of the same weight for diferent animals,  bears get a 3 blade due to easy penetration and thick fur, i like to cut as much as possible on them so i dont have to track
everything else gets a 2 blade
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: BowHuntingFool on March 11, 2010, 02:35:00 PM
I'm pretty confident that my set up would kill just about anything in NA. The only thing I do different is my small game arrows, that are old arrows that have small game heads on that are footed! Otherwise the same arrow for everything bigger! I might check out different BH just to check em out!
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Zbearclaw on March 11, 2010, 03:23:00 PM
Until bison or buffalo tags are in my pocket I will keep it the same.

I am building a longer arrow to accomodate my lengthened draw, but once the details are nailed down it will remain the same until I change the bow.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Ragnarok Forge on March 11, 2010, 04:50:00 PM
I have been playing with arrows a lot, just tinkering. Despite the tinkering I shoot the same arrows for stump shooting, 3D's, target league, hunter league and hunting.  I am with the prior post that shooting one arrow helps me with consistancy and accuracy.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Chris Shelton on March 11, 2010, 07:08:00 PM
I have the same arrows in my quiver year round, but the tip always changes.  I almost always have broadheads in my quiver, but I also almost always have judos.  I wish I was able to afford to shoot broadheads at squirrels so I wouldnt have to switch arrows for different critters.  But other than that I am the same!
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: on March 11, 2010, 08:26:00 PM
I like to shoot the fastest arrow I can during the spring and summer. I jump up 70 grains for the fall. I switch to the heavier arrows in August.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: bushytail on March 11, 2010, 08:42:00 PM
I shoot the same arrows for groundhog up to deer.But i use small game points for small game.
Title: Re: Changing hunting arrow to cater towards certain game
Post by: Ray Hammond on March 11, 2010, 08:43:00 PM
same arrows for everything up to elk.