Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: ozy clint on April 28, 2009, 08:42:00 PM

Title: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: ozy clint on April 28, 2009, 08:42:00 PM
i think about bowhunting alot and while putting up some fibreglass insulation today i got to thinking, why aren't they around any more.
the only ones i've seen are in the dark abyss of a cupboard at home.
of course everybody knows about solid fibreglass bowfishing arrows but what about the normal ones?

anyone got experiences to share?
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Overspined on April 28, 2009, 09:11:00 PM
they are not straight
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: forrest-hunter on April 28, 2009, 09:14:00 PM
I still have some Bears I shoot. The problem with them is that they shatter very easly. Bear made some caps you could put between the arrow  and the point or broadhead which helped but if you glance the arrow of a hard surface it tends to break the fiberglass.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: jcar315 on April 28, 2009, 09:16:00 PM
Years ago my Dad shot them and I do remember them breaking alot (neither of us was very good!) 35 years later they are leading a nice quiet life as my Mom's plant stakes.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Orion on April 28, 2009, 09:23:00 PM
Fiberglass was quite popular for a while.  The best, micro-flites, were straight enough and generally fairly durable.  But it was fairly easy to ram the insert and point into the shaft on a hard hit, splitting the shaft.  Folks didn't think to put collars on them back then like they're doing now with carbons.  Aluminums took a hard frontal hit a little better and were offered in at least as many spines and eventually displaced the fiberglass.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: reddogge on April 28, 2009, 09:25:00 PM
I killed many a deer with them but Easton aluminum surpassed it for straightness and toughness so they were rendered obsolete.  I have two DuraFlight #8s left and they shoot as good as anything out there though.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: joe skipp on April 28, 2009, 09:33:00 PM
I shot fiberglass arrows from Graphlex and MJ Log and they were good arrows once you found the right shaft spine. The only problem was obtaining inserts and they did have a tendency to crack right behind the point.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: redfish on April 28, 2009, 10:05:00 PM
I've got a bunch of shafts that are semi-straight. I have a hard time finding a way to get a nock on them straight.
I have a bunch set up as flu=flus and I do carry a few with me with some old sharpened broadheads for use on hogs/whatever. No great loss if it is broken/lost.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Raminshooter on April 28, 2009, 10:23:00 PM
What others have remarked on...not very good for shooting stumps with.  Cedar was a much better material all around than these were.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: d. ward on April 28, 2009, 10:34:00 PM
I've shot several critters includeing elk with micro flight arrows and never had any problems with them.
One problem is the cost of manufacturing them its not cost effective anymore.Another thing is there are not many tubular fiberglass manufactures around these days.Their all makeing carbons.bd
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Chuck Hoopes on April 29, 2009, 02:12:00 AM
I use to order Shafts from the old Herters catalog.  I never did get em to fly all that well-- I used a straight fletch, which likely did not help any.  They did shatter/split w/direct hits on hard objects.  I ve been shooting nothing but cedar for the past 20yrs, and I don't see that changing.  Sure miss reading that Old Herters catalog,though.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: sweet old bill on April 29, 2009, 06:00:00 AM
Ah the old tan fiberglass shaft from Herter's, I got my first doz from them at 15 and they came in 2 yellow fletch and one black feather and the tan shaft. I just found in a old tool box the first alum fly box from Herter's. We would leave the catalog in the bathroom for all our dreams.

Bill
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Rob DiStefano on April 29, 2009, 08:37:00 AM
imo, glass just isn't as straight/durable as carbons, and perhaps more expensive to manufacture.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Cody Roiter on April 29, 2009, 08:43:00 AM
I buy them any time I can.. There the best shooting arrows I have shot in a long time.. I have all makes and find they all shoot great for me.. I can't get carbobs to shoot the same as the old glass arrows.. I use them for every thing...

But like they guys say Carons are better but I going to stay with glass tell there no more....

Take Care guys,

Cody
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: hvyhitter on April 29, 2009, 10:18:00 AM
Shot a lot of them in the 70's. We used to wrap the first inch or so with a double layer of heavy thread(used for fishing rod guides)and coated it with epoxy. This "footing" stopped the insert from wedging in as much.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: d. ward on April 29, 2009, 11:27:00 AM
wow this book took me a little while to find 1957 here's a pic of a fiberglass arrow.bd   (http://i264.photobucket.com/albums/ii175/bowdocsarchery/ice001.jpg)
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: dino on April 29, 2009, 12:25:00 PM
Nothing like a Microflite 12 with a Magnum broadhead!  Devistating combination.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: SELFBOW19953 on April 29, 2009, 12:50:00 PM
Joe,

If you've got any Graphlex or MJ Log shafts you want to part with, let me know. I've got MJ 6's, 8's, 9's, and 11's.

Phil
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: CaptJack on April 29, 2009, 04:04:00 PM
I've been shooting Easton X7s since I started shooting in 1961 (7178-T9 alloy)
Nothing has ever come close until the new carbons.
I still have so many X7 target arrows and XX78 hunting arrows I've never had the desire to switch to carbons.

Fiberglass was never even as good as the cheaper XX75 aluminums (7075-T9 alloy)

but I do shoot sold glass bowfishing arrows
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: frank bullitt on April 29, 2009, 10:38:00 PM
I have some of the Graphlex shafts. I wish I had more! A freind I got them from, sold the remaining shafts to Dan Quillian in the early '90s. If you look at the old TBM mag classifieds you will see his ad for these! Stacy Groscup also used these in his exibition shoots! They were great shafts! Good shootin, Steve.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Markus77 on April 30, 2009, 02:54:00 AM
I havent shoot any fiberglass arrows, but I have not found a durable carbon arrow yet. They brake for anything, pushing the judo or blunthead into the shaft.The best so far is Beman ICS bowhunter 340, and the worst "traditional only" from 3rivers. Which carbonarrows do you use that are really durable?
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Old York on April 30, 2009, 09:37:00 AM
I wish Gordon still made their Glashafts. The ones I have are tough, straight, and 'heavy'. Some are footed with an aluminium 1-1/2" stub and they're almost indestructible.

Sure, they split and have spine & weight variances like carbons; you just don't have to stuff 'em with weight tubes LOL!
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: turkey65 on April 30, 2009, 10:26:00 AM
I've been shooting microflites since the fifties, very durable and always straight. I solved the splitting problem by inserting a dowel right up to the insert this way if you hit something hard there wasn't any give and it with stood the impact. I still use the remaining I have and with the shaft sleeved and broadhead installed on a #8 shaft total weight comes out to 650 grains, talk about penetration and a quiet bow? Being a member of the old fart club I'll continue to buy and use any I can find at yard sales etc.Used them all Graphflex, Browning, Herters, Durashaft, and others not well known microflites are the best.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: d. ward on April 30, 2009, 10:38:00 AM
If you like shooting glass shafts you can still purchase off gbay new old stock Tough Tips sold by Bear Archery.Its a small sleeve that goes on between the head and the insert.It slip over the shaft about 1/4-3/8 inch to prevert spliting.bd
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: JimB on April 30, 2009, 11:27:00 AM
Fiberglass arrows started fading out about the time the the mechanical bows came on the scene-mid '70's.Nobody wanted heavy arrows.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Old York on April 30, 2009, 12:31:00 PM
JimB nailed it, dead on.

Easton even started marketing their aluminiums with "Standard", "Lite", "SuperLite", "UltraLite". Super hi-speed arrows, smacking deer with a dust-mote, go figure.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: 44charlie on April 30, 2009, 04:44:00 PM
got my best buck ever with a glass arrow and they make great takedown arrows! i still have one from the first dozen i ever owned!
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: Rob DiStefano on May 01, 2009, 07:49:00 AM
imo, there's nothing that wrong about the glass shafts i used to use, way back when - micro-flite and gordon.  if micro-flites were available today at a price point equal to, or less, than beman ics carbons, i'd definitely be in queue to buy a few dozen for my heavier draw weight bows.  

for whatever reasons as to why they were all terminated, it's a moot point at this date and time.  it would probably be a risky marketing venture to tool up for glass shafts today, and even with mass production the retail cost would be at least equal to carbon shafting.  

if glass shafting does emerge on the market, i think carbon will still outsell glass because, imo, carbon shafts will always be lighter than glass shafts (comparing spine) and that allows a huge latitude range of front end weights for really high foc arrows.    

ymmv.
Title: Re: why didn't fibreglass arrows become popular??
Post by: bear1336 on May 03, 2009, 06:34:00 AM
I sure had a lot of great hunts using mico flite arrows.  Sure would like to have a couple doz no 6 or 7 arrows.