Trad Gang

Main Boards => PowWow => Topic started by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 09:02:00 AM

Title: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 09:02:00 AM
I am window shopping for a new Deer Bow. I have read some really nice things about the Slick Stick. What is the grip like? In pics it looks like a recurve grip, medium to high which I would like. The guy I talked to a 3R said it is still more like a longbow grip than a recurve grip. I have a Bear Montana and with my carpal tunnel in my bow hand I can't get good with it and it kills me. I own a Bodnik Kiowa and it is a sweet shooting bow, even though it is short but the grip is perfect and it is very accurate. Was thinking about another Bodnik but a longer one and see what I can do with it. I draw to 28.5 if that matters.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: riser on February 22, 2017, 09:11:00 AM
I had a 64" Slick Stick made for me, drawing 45#@30".  Points and shoots well.  Very smooth. Grip is low, thin.  It reminds me of a 1959 Bear Kodiak Special.  Simple bow that zips an arrow.  None-min handshock.

Check out youtube.  There are several videos from Wolfie Hughes (and a few others > ie  Karma tales) on the slick stick.

I'm very happy with my Slick Stick.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Trenton G. on February 22, 2017, 09:32:00 AM
I shot one in Kalamazoo and I didn't really care for it. It felt really unstable to me. It was fast and smooth though.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 10:02:00 AM
Thanks for the feedback. I am thinking about a production 58" in 50#. I don't feel I'm good enough to get anything custom just yet. Besides I enjoy buying more bows. So I see what they mean that the grip is still longbow-ish. I was also looking at a Mohawk but leaning towards the Slick Stick, I am not a fan of the color combination on the newer model Mohawks. I also see that Kustom King is going to sell the new Hunter 60" recurve next month, which is a possibility.

Riser, what weight arrows do you shoot out of it and do you have any chrono numbers? I don't care for the whisper strings so that's the first thing I replace.

Trenton, what length do you draw to? Was it a 58" that you shot?
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Trenton G. on February 22, 2017, 10:09:00 AM
Kevin, I believe that it was a 58" bow. My draw length is just under 29", and the bow handled that without an issuel. I think that it just felt so odd to me since I'm used to shooting longer bows.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 10:51:00 AM
OK good to know. I am a recurve guy and like a Grizzly to SK length. I could never get the hang of a long bow although I would like to. My Montana is not working out how I expected.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: riser on February 22, 2017, 11:04:00 AM
I shoot xx75 aluminum 2016 Easton Tributes with 150-175 grain points. I don't have a chrono, but it is quick indeed.

I wanted a 64" bow to minimize any "stability" issues. The Slick Stick weighs about 1 pound. It IS light.  I never shot a Slick Stick of any length before ordering my 64" bow. I personally felt 58-60" was just too short for my desires.  There is a guy in my 3d club that had a similarly designed highly r/D design 58" longbow. It was 55+#@28" and very low mass, 1 lb. The guy who owned this bow is a very good shooter, but he struggled with it for accuracy.

To ME ( and me alone), I thought the combination of low mass, high draw weight, and short amo length worked against each other.  

I knew I wanted a longer, lower draw weight version.  That's what I got, and it is a delight to shoot. Due to the low mass, it IS less forgiving if you don't use good release/ follow through.  It makes me a better shooter, and I shoot it pretty well now.

I am experimenting with a Big Jim's strap on quiver on this bow. It does add some mass and stability. So far so good.

There is no way around the fact a 58-60" longbow is low in mass. It IS less forgiving to sloppy techniques. Don't blame the how-to that's what it is. I'd opt for at least the 60" amo Slick Stick with a 45# draw weight (@ your draw length) if you want a "stock" Slick Stick.  

I'm not sure if Bearpaw/Bodnik still offers a custom Slick Stick option or not. Might be another option for you. Email them. Another option is the Bearpaw/Bodnick amo 64" Dakota longbow. Kustom King Archery has them. $350+ ???  Looks like a nice bow (and 30 year warranty too).
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 04:04:00 PM
Thanks, this is the kind of honest feedback I was looking for. As stated earlier I already own a Bodnik Kiowa and I'm sure the Slick Stick is a great quality bow and is very shoot-able in the right hands. I don't think it is a bow I would buy without at least shooting it though, it might not be for me. I would jump on the Mohawk in a heartbeat but the color scheme I just can't take, it looks like a Samick Nighthawk Clone and I've had the unfortunate experience of owning a "bad" samick.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Biathlonman on February 22, 2017, 04:42:00 PM
I had one come through.  Probably the nicest production bow I've tried.  I thought the grip was like a low to medium recurve grip.  The one I had was fast and quiet.  I don't know if the bow was not smooth or heavier then marked but that was my only complaint.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: riser on February 22, 2017, 04:54:00 PM
KevinK

I seem to remember seeing a youtube video by Wolfie Hughes ( a great instinctive shooter, lives in Wales) reviewing the Bodnik Mohawk.  I believe his opinion could be condensed to "it's OK, nothing special.".   I think he was being kind to Bearpaw/Bodnik.  It certainly was not an enthusiastic positive review.  He DID like the Slick Stick , and Quick Stick in his other videos.

Try to find it.   Sounded like "no wow factor."

Just my humble reporting.  Do some research yourself.  It may indeed be a great bow for you.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 06:33:00 PM
I got interested in Bodnik because of their 30 year warranty (if bought through Bearpaw USA it is lifetime). I had a bad experience with some bad Samicks. And yes I do take good care of my gear but it does get heavy use. In addition to my 3 Samick purchases I also own a Vintage Grizzly, a new Bear Montana and my wife has a new Kmag. I can say compared to my 40 plus year old Grizzly I am not impressed by the new Bear quality or finish. It isn't bad but doesn't compare to the old ones that are still in good shape. My Kiowa, basic, plain but you can just tell a big difference in the quality of the construction. It has the typical "rough satin" Bodnik finish which I didn't care for at first but learned to really like, especially when I have a ton of string wax on my fingers. And I'm also impressed with the Kiowa's shootability. I bought the bow for a special purpose turkey blind bow and it is my most accurate bow I own (at least me shooting it). I figure if a 52" by Bodnik is that accurate then a 58 or 60" bow should be even easier to shoot.I thought the old finish on the Mohawk was "OK" Back when the limbs and riser were the same color (See Kustom King or Lancaster's site) but the new color (Bearpaw USA and 3R) just give me a headache to look at.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 06:36:00 PM
And Yes I'm familiar with Wolfie. He is a great shot. Fun to watch him shoot but usually the opposite is true because he's so good of a shot and makes below average bows look good. So definitely something to consider.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Rough Run on February 22, 2017, 06:43:00 PM
I have one of the Black Forest bows, sold by Kustom King and made by Bearpaw/Bodnik.  64", marked 50#@28, but #53@29" (my draw, and KK scaled for me.)  The grip is a little thinner and lower than I am used to from my recurve, but I am adjusting pretty quickly.  I love the bow.  It is smooth, easy to point, and doesn't feel like 50+ pounds.  Although it is very light, I don't feel any hand shock or vibration.  It smokes the 2016s with either 125 or 145 gr points - I can't tell any difference.  The Dakota that is coming soon may be the replacement for the Black Forest.

I like it so much, I recently purchased a used 60" Slick Stick, #45@28".  And I was excited to find one that was 60" instead of 58".  I just like, and seem to shoot better, with bows in the 60-64" range.  Going to try 1916s to start, because I like to keep all my points at 125 or 150 gr for simplicity.  

Unlike most, it seems, I like the Whisper string that was on the Black Forest.  All my Easton, GT, Marco & Arizona nocks fit it well, and it is very quiet.  I have tried other strings, but they didn't offer any advantages (that I could perceive) over the Whisper string.

Good luck with your search.  I hope you find what you are looking for, and enjoy yours as much as I like mine.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: riser on February 22, 2017, 08:17:00 PM
I noticed Kustom King has two Bearpaw one-piece recurves new for spring 2017.  One is a 58" RECURVE version of the Slick Stick.  The other is a 60" Hunter ( bamboo limbs, bubinga riser).

 http://www.kustomkingarchery.com/Bodnik-Bows/products/52/  

They look interesting in design and quality (with lifetime warranty).  Good luck.

Or   find Wing Red Wing Hunter ( amo 58") recurve from the 1960's ( Houston or Head Ski mfg).
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 22, 2017, 09:03:00 PM
Funny you mentioned the Wing Riser. I have had my eye on one and almost pulled the trigger. I love vintage bows. The way they made bows back then doesn't compare to production bows these days, Bodnik is very close but if you want same or better quality you have to go custom anymore.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Westkyhunter on February 22, 2017, 11:54:00 PM
I've posted before on other "slick stick" threads about mine. It's called the "little stick" which is the older version of the slick stick. Mines 45@28" 58" and I've been shooting it almost two years now. I draw just shy of 28". I've had nothing but good times with this bow shooting a wide range of arrow setups and spines. All the carbons were bare shafted but the river cane and spruce shafts weren't. They all fly perfect for me. I've had zero problems with stability either. I think that has a lot to do with what your used to shooting and how bad you want to learn a different length and mass weight bow. It seems to me some guys shoot a short bow a few days and say they don't like it because its unstable. And it's probably not compared to their much longer and heavier bows that they've been shooting for ten years. However if you get one and try it a while and honestly practice with it for a longer period of time I believe you'd really enjoy it, especially for hunting. I too have severe corpal tunnel in both wrists. I use a wrist support strap for my string hand and it really helps. I wrap it really tight and it kinda locks and supports my wrist and hand together. May be something you can try. Most days I can shoot but some days I can't draw even my lightest bows which are in the 35lb range. I won't go into detail about the different arrow specs since I've discussed them several times on here already. You should be able to pull them up with the search function. My "little stick" helped me fill four whitetail tags this past fall. I just love short bows!lol
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 28, 2017, 06:31:00 PM
So I have been watching the 45 and 50# Slick Stick on 3 Rivers website. I have seen it be available then quickly be on back order. This morning I saw they had a 50#, RH in charcoal in stock so I placed the order. It said in stock until I got the email it is on back order. I called and 3R said it should be fulfilled in a few days. Hopefully I like it but at least if I don't it seems that they sell quickly.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Rough Run on February 28, 2017, 06:52:00 PM
I have been eyeballing the Slick Sticks for a year, and just bought a used model off the Classifieds.  I got really lucky in that this bow was a 60" model, which is no longer offered - I thought I missed my chance.  #45@28" was just what I wanted, too, and the bow is in immaculate condition, really well cared for.  Lucky me, a late birthday gift to myself!

I have only put about 5 dozen shots through it with both 1916 & 2016 shafts, but it seems to handle them both with no variation that I can perceive, but there is only 12gr difference in total weight.  The 1916s seem to be the better shaft - or maybe it is just my imagination - but the bow flat out screams those arrows.  It shoots where I look.  It draws to my 29" draw with no stacking.  It is very light, yet I feel no shock in my hand or arm.

In short, I must be in for something bad, because I got so lucky with this bow!  I love it!  I know it is still the honeymoon, but I have 2 others that I really, really like and it took significantly longer to get there with them.

For an affordable, factory bow it is hard to beat, in my opinion, for experimenting with length and style/type before sinking significantly more on a custom that may not fit the bill.  And you may get lucky like me!

I hope you enjoy yours just as much!
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on February 28, 2017, 06:56:00 PM
I hope I do like it as much as the guys that love theirs. I only draw to 28.5" but my carpal tunnel doesn't handle a traditional longbow grip. I did order a bow saddle just in case I need it.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Rough Run on February 28, 2017, 07:06:00 PM
If the grip hasn't changed, you may like it.  It is slender, but not skinny - seems more like my my recurve, not a high wrist but swelling more in the palm than my other longbows.  And it has a bit of a thumb locator, which I find very nice.  I have never shot a Montana, but the grip definitely appears noticeably different.  My bow has a leather wrap grip drying on it now, and I hope to get its final fit, cut & stitching done tomorrow.  I want to shoot some more!
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Fletcher on February 28, 2017, 08:31:00 PM
This Mad Dog in the Sponsor Classifieds looks pretty good:  http://tradgang.com/noncgi/ultimatebb.php?ubb=get_topic;f=48;t=002864

Usually some excellent deals in the regular classifieds, too.

I know nothing about the Bodnik.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on March 07, 2017, 05:46:00 PM
I got it yesterday. Been too busy getting a string ready and tuning wood arrows for it. First impressions were that the grip isn't bad at all. More comfortable than my vintage Grizzly. Next thing was, wow this is a very smooth drawing bow. Mine is marked 50# and the first few inches of draw seemed a bit heavy but after that it seemed a little lighter than my 45# grizzly. Next thing was my 55-60 spined wood arrows were very weak. This surprised me as my Kiowa liked weak arrows. It also seemed very fast even with the "heavy" arrows I was shooting. My wife shot it as well and really liked it. She only has a 25" draw and we are working on getting her draw weight up to a hunting weight. So today I took it to my local shop and put it on the same scale I always use. 45# @25" and 54# @28". Explains the weak acting arrows. I am not upset, I thought it was actually on the low side.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Westkyhunter on March 09, 2017, 10:08:00 PM
Congrats on the new slick stick kevink. I think you'll do well with it and really enjoy it. I haven't used wood arrows a lot but the ones I have been using shoot great with my Bodnik little stick. They shoot where I look just like my carbons only a tad higher at the same ranges. As said before mine is 45# and I spine my homemade wood arrows as close to 45# as I can normally and shoot 125gr points on them. They're 30.5" before tapering for nocks and points. As much as I have read telling people to shoot 10-15# heavier spine than actual draw weight with woods you would think I'm way under spined! I do barrel taper mine though 10" on the front and 10" on the back so maybe this has something to do with it. I just finished up another dozen spruce shafts and made them a little stiffer to see if I can tell any difference. I've yet to fletch them though.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: sandlapper on March 09, 2017, 11:42:00 PM
I Bought a 60 inch 55# from KK, It broke at the riser, sent it back and received a new 58 inch. The warranty is very good. It is a pretty quick bow, and I like mine just fine. The bowstring is pretty small in diameter, and I had to place a second nock below arrow to keep it from sliding down upon release. I really like the size and weight of the bow, I think you would like the bow very much.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: KevinK on March 10, 2017, 08:40:00 PM
Well so far it is a great bow, but I think I have to get another. Not a bad thing at all. My wife really likes it and shoots well with it. She's only 5-0" with a 25" draw and I was struggling to find an effective traditional hunting weapon for her. Well I think we found it. 54#@ 28 and 45# @25. It is strange that it feels so much lighter of a pull than it actually is, like you're pulling on a really long bow with extra leverage. But handling it doesn't even feel like it's a 58" bow. Definitely best of both worlds. Surprisingly she shoots it fine without fatigue so I might have to get another 50# for myself or if I coudld verify that a 55# isn't really 59 or 60# pick it up for myself. At her height and draw length I know it will be tougher to find her a bow than for myself.
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Westkyhunter on March 10, 2017, 11:11:00 PM
Wow sandlapper that's the first one I've heard of breaking! It's good they stood by their warranty and replaced it.

KevinK sounds like you've lost that bow for sure!! I think you got the right idea though. If she likes it that much and it fits her that good I'd just get another one. I'm surprised the first one is off as much as it is weight wise but anything is possible. If that one draws as light and smooth to ya and it's 4#'s heavier just imagine how good a true 50#'er will feel and shoot!
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: gvdocholiday on March 12, 2017, 10:54:00 AM
How far past center is the sight window cut?
Title: Re: Anyone own a Bodnik Slick Stick? Thoughts?
Post by: Rough Run on March 12, 2017, 02:48:00 PM
I believe they are cut to center, but not past.